Telegram founder arrested: Who wants to arrest him? Summary of opinions from various parties

This article is machine translated
Show original

Written by: Deng Tong, Jinse Finance

On August 25, Jinse Finance reported that Telegram founder Pavel Durov was detained at a French airport. In addition, French police also searched Durov's property. Sources said that the possible reason for Durov's detention was the existence of drug trafficking, gun black market and child pornography on the Telegram platform. Previously, Telegram refused to cooperate with the police.

What charges will Telegram founder Pavel Durov face? How will Telegram respond to this? Is TON still promising? What are the responses from all parties, including the Russian government? Jinse Finance has compiled information from various sources for readers.

Related articles can be found at: "The Arrested Telegram Founder: Legendary Entrepreneurship History and His Cryptocurrency Ambitions"

1. Who is Pavel Durov?

Pavel Durov is a Russian programmer and billionaire, the founder of VKontakte and Telegram. He was a recipient of the Russian Presidential and Russian Government Scholarships during his student years, and a three-time Potanin Scholarship recipient. He was called the Russian Mark Zuckerberg by HuffPost.

In 2013, Durov created Telegram. Since 2016, he has been included in the Forbes list of the 200 richest Russians. On April 6, 2021, Forbes magazine published a new list of the world's richest people, in which he ranked 112th, with an estimated wealth of about $17.2 billion. According to the official French government gazette, Durov became a French citizen on August 25, 2021. On August 24, 2024, he was arrested by French police in France for "Telegram facilitating money laundering crimes" and detained by agents of the French National Anti-Fraud Office.

Durov became a French citizen in August 2021. He moved himself and Telegram to Dubai in 2017, and according to French media reports, he also obtained UAE citizenship. In addition, he is also a citizen of the Caribbean twin-island nation of Saint Kitts and Nevis.

II. Details of Pavel Durov’s arrest and the charges he will face

According to French news website TF1: Durov was arrested after traveling from Azerbaijan with a woman and her bodyguard to Paris's Le Bourget airport, which specializes in servicing private jets.

It is understood the billionaire rarely travels in Europe, perhaps to avoid being detained in this way as the warrant for his arrest is only valid within France.

TF1 predicts that Durov could be indicted on Sunday on "multiple charges: terrorism, drugs, conspiracy, fraud, money laundering, receiving stolen property, pedophile content," and possibly more.

According to preliminary investigations, Durov was the subject of a search warrant issued by OFMIN, France's investigative agency for combating child sexual exploitation.

A source noted: "He made a mistake tonight. We don't know why... Was this flight just a layover? Whatever the case, he's locked up."

3. The foreshadowing of Telegram’s regulatory pressure

In addition, Telegram’s regulatory issues may have also laid the groundwork for the founder’s arrest.

According to French newspaper Le Monde, the Telegram platform, which is often criticized for its lack of regulation, only carries out partial and very limited bans.

Russia began blocking Telegram in 2018 after the app refused to comply with a court order allowing state security services to access its users’ encrypted messages. The move had little impact on Telegram’s availability in Russia but sparked massive protests in Moscow and drew criticism from non-governmental organizations.

“I would rather be free than take orders from anyone,” Durov told US journalist Tucker Carlson in April. He left Russia to find a home for his company, working in Berlin, London, Singapore and San Francisco.

In a video of an interview with Telegram founder Pavel Durov by Tucker Carlson, a well-known American political commentator and journalist, Pavel Durov revealed some key information: "Whenever we come to the United States, we receive too much attention from the FBI and other security agencies. The last time I went to the United States, I brought an engineer who worked at Telegram. Cybersecurity officials or agents tried to secretly hire my engineer behind my back. They were curious about which open source libraries were integrated into Telegram's application and tried to convince him to use certain open source tools that acted as backdoors." "I have personally experienced similar pressure in the United States. Whenever I go to the United States, I am greeted by two FBI agents at the airport asking questions. My understanding is that they want to establish a relationship to better control Telegram."

5qC309yeCwslsdOePj0lo23P2bValwjZs7suaIj0.jpeg

Telegram's growing popularity has also sparked scrutiny over security and data breaches in several European countries, including France. In May, EU technology regulators said they had contacted Telegram because it was approaching a key usage standard that could subject it to stricter requirements under a landmark EU online content legislation.

Due to the lack of regulatory rules, Telegram has become a refuge for many political movements that are banned on all other platforms , such as the conspiracy movement QAnon, and Hamas, which has dozens of official and unofficial accounts there. Telegram is one of Hamas' official channels. The group, called "Hamas Movement," has about 150,000 subscribers, and the channel posted a video of Hamas activists kidnapping French-Israeli hostage Mia Schem during the attack on the Nova Tribe music festival on October 7, 2023. But Telegram's moderation and supervision have not improved significantly.

Jackson Hinkle, an independent political commentator in the United States, said on X that an anti-Israel hacker had stolen billions of bytes of sensitive Israeli data and published confidential information on Telegram. Telegram rejected Israel's request to censor it. Telegram founder Pavel Durov was arrested in France and faces 20 years in prison.

pWyOiryzr8vizBH9AkXID50HbaejGmsNSod3jabz.jpeg

According to Reuters, Telegram has influence in Russia, Ukraine and the former Soviet republics. It has become a key source of information for Russia's war in Ukraine, with officials in Moscow and Kiev using it heavily. Some analysts have called the app a "virtual battlefield" for the war.

4. TON and Telegram’s response

On August 25, TON responded to Durov’s arrest by posting on X:

TON Community Statement


Following the recent news regarding Telegram founder Pavel Durov, we want to reassure everyone that the TON community remains strong and fully operational.

As a community committed to free speech and decentralization, we stand firmly with Pavel during this challenging time. Pavel has been a loyal advocate for these values, and we believe his efforts to advance an open and decentralized internet will continue to inspire millions of people.

The TON community remains focused on our mission, and we will continue to work to uphold these principles around the world. We encourage everyone to remain calm, united, and continue to build as we navigate this situation together. Thank you for your continued support.


TON community.

ytbSEWgiCi3mKM1mzqMVfL8cPMTINOxh93A8M41J.jpeg

Subsequently, TON’s Official Twitter added the Resistance Dog logo hand-painted by Telegram’s founder in 2018 to its avatar. According to the TON Foundation, the dog in a hoodie (also known as the Resistance Dog) was originally hand-painted and named by Pavel Durov, the founder of Telegram and TON, in 2018. REDO has been the (un)official mascot of Telegram’s vision of “resisting” censorship since then.

cYZEtXy9VeIOGmcqNj9PQYh4wcHDJVyrLJ1Az6k5.jpeg

Telegram Wallet also posted on its official channel: “We are closely following the recent news about Telegram founder Pavel Durov, but these events will not affect the operation of Wallet in any way.”

On August 25, Telegram issued its first official statement on the arrest of its CEO Pavel Durov. “It is not clear what exactly Durov has been charged with, or if he has been arrested at all. There have been various reports that he may have been arrested for a lack of management of the Telegram platform, but without official confirmation from the French government or further explanation from Telegram, the facts remain unclear. Telegram CEO Pavel Durov has nothing to hide and travels frequently in Europe.”

AOUOw1RvYl2Wa2U7c8WpIX0srSsMwS0akkLJcGSz.jpeg

On August 26, Telegram released a statement on the X platform in response to the arrest of its founder:

1. Telegram complies with EU law, including the Digital Services Act - its audit meets industry standards and is constantly improving.

2. Telegram CEO Pavel Durov is not hiding and travels frequently in Europe.

3. It is absurd to claim that a platform or platform owner should be held responsible for abuse on the platform.

4. Nearly one billion users around the world use Telegram as a means of communication and an important source of information.

5. The team is awaiting a prompt resolution to this situation.

8IHmuVm4qclvGOny3MgF5U6CUSHTbVQrZQkZoNGR.jpeg

5. How do people from all sides respond to the arrest of Pavel Durov?

  • The Russian Foreign Ministry said that the Russian Embassy in France has taken necessary measures to understand the circumstances of Durov's arrest. Russian media "Russia Today" (RT) reported that Russian State Duma Deputy Chairman Vladislav Davankov urged the Russian Foreign Ministry to take immediate action to try to get France to release Durov.

    Davankov wrote on Telegram on the 25th: "Almost no one has made a greater contribution to the development of digital services in Russia and the world than him... We need to rescue him. I have urged Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov to take action and call on the French authorities to release Durov. The arrest may be politically motivated in order to obtain the personal information of Telegram users. We cannot allow this to happen."

    Davankov believes that "illegal activities exist on all social platforms, but no one arrests or imprisons their owners, and this should not happen." He also declared that if the French government refuses to release Durov, Russia should "make every effort" to send Durov to the UAE or Russia, "of course, the premise is that he agrees." In response to this incident, Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Zakharova said on the 25th that the Russian Embassy in France has taken necessary measures and is understanding Durov's situation.

  • Medvedev responded to Durov’s arrest on Telegram on the 25th: “A long time ago, I asked Durov why he was unwilling to cooperate with law enforcement agencies on serious crimes? He replied at the time, ‘This is my principled position.’ But I told him, ‘This will cause serious problems in any country.’”

    "He thought his biggest problem was being in Russia, so he left and then got citizenship or a residence permit in another country. He wanted to be a great 'world citizen' who could live well without a motherland. As the Latin proverb says: Ubi bene ibi patria! Wherever you live well, that is your motherland."

    "But he miscalculated. To all the enemies we now face together, he is Russian, and therefore unpredictable and dangerous, and he has a different blood."

    “He’s not Musk, and he’s not Zuckerberg (who, by the way, are actively cooperating with the FBI).”

    "Durov should finally understand that the motherland, like the times, is not something that can be chosen..."

    7ekKySrG0mDG3JsSnYLRjkL2v9c2pS857hPFgW0I.jpeg

  • After Telegram founder Pavel Durov was arrested in Paris , Italian Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Infrastructure and Transport Matteo Salvini speculated that the next person "to be forced to shut up" would be American entrepreneur Musk. "We in Europe have already moved towards censorship, towards this notorious system." "Long live freedom, thought and speech. Who will be forced to shut up next? Elon Musk?"

  • Musk commented on X: "Telegram CEO Pavel Durov was arrested by French police" and said "this is to promote the First Amendment of the US Constitution." He also sarcastically said "It's Europe in 2030, and you were executed for liking a meme." Note: The First Amendment of the US Constitution is part of the US Bill of Rights, which guarantees citizens the freedom to express their opinions in public and political affairs. Its main contents include: freedom of speech, freedom of the press and other rights.

    Afterwards, Musk released a video with the tag "FreePavel" to once again support Telegram founder Pavel Durov. In the video, Pavel Durov was interviewed and said, "Musk's acquisition of X has made speech more free. This is a great progress. Humanity needs more social media like X and Telegram that uphold freedom of speech."

8oJAKjafgBqQEWDvIujbXRRwJJFJ37OykIL8esT4.jpeg

  • American journalist Tucker Carlson posted on X platform and attached an interview with Durov in the post: Pavel Durov left Russia when the government tried to control his social media company Telegram. But in the end, it was not Putin who arrested him on the grounds of allowing the public to exercise free speech. It was a Western country, an ally of the Biden administration and an enthusiastic NATO member who locked him up. Pavel Durov sits in a French prison tonight, which is a living warning to any platform owner who refuses to censor the truth at the request of governments and intelligence agencies. Darkness is rapidly descending on this once free world.

Gcpn9IgKI4grNnon20hc8qCY8w95vwp1Q7llba5c.jpeg

  • Edward Snowden, the whistleblower of "Prism Gate": "The arrest of Telegram CEO Pavel Durov is a violation of basic human rights such as freedom of expression and the right to association. I am shocked and deeply saddened that Macron has fallen to the point of taking hostages to gain access to private communications. This is a shame not only for France, but also for the whole world."

    OomnhbuhVTWYiCV0vtXwoL6ykdUa04L1fDy4J04U.jpeg

  • Alex Thorn, head of research at crypto asset management firm Galaxy Digital: "My guess is they will accuse Telegram of not complying with the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA), which is a really bad law that holds platforms responsible for illegal user content."

  • Andrei Grachev, founder of DWF Labs: We can't do much, but I decided to support as much as I can. I have purchased about $500,000 worth of TON on the open market and will keep it on the chain until FREEDUROV ends.

  • Chris Pavlovski, founder of online video platform Rumble: "I'm a little late and here's the thing - I just left Europe safely. France has already threatened Rumble, and now they have crossed the red line and arrested Telegram founder Pavel Durov, reportedly because he did not censor speech. Rumble will not tolerate this behavior and will use all legal means to fight for freedom of speech as a universal human right. We are currently fighting in the French courts and hope that Pavel Durov will be released immediately." It is reported that Rumble is an online video platform with web hosting and cloud service businesses, headquartered in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, and its US headquarters is located in Longboat Key, Florida.

6. Impact on TON Price

Due to the arrest of Telegram founder Pavel Durov, the price of TON, which is linked to Telegram, fell by 25% at one point. However, market analysis of some technical and market factors indicates that TON may rebound sharply in the coming weeks.

A similar situation occurred on BNB. On April 30, CZ was sentenced in the United States and BNB fell 13.5%. However, when the verdict was settled, BNB rose nearly 35% from its low and hit a high of nearly $700 on June 6.

When news of legal disputes breaks, the market panics and sells as traders rush to protect their investments from potential repercussions. However, once the initial shock subsides, the market reassesses the situation more rationally, and the same psychological pattern may also appear in Toncoin.

The arrest of Pavel Durov could be seen as a major red flag, causing traders to exit their positions, leading to a sharp drop in price. But if the market later believes that the arrest was an isolated incident that does not fundamentally disrupt the Toncoin ecosystem, traders may begin to view the drop as an opportunity for panic buying.

From a technical perspective, TON is trading within a well-defined ascending channel, as shown on the daily chart.

NiTwmSbGhBw9haHg8pqD4a9SKEiqGJscqzNE2A1f.jpeg

TON/USDT daily price chart. Source: TradingView

The TON/USDT pair rebounded from the channel’s lower trendline, which has been acting as a strong support since it formed earlier this year.

Toncoin’s futures market data also suggests traders’ confidence is growing. After Durov’s arrest, TON’s open interest (OI) rose to $303.62 million, the highest level since July. Meanwhile, its eight-hour funding rate rose to a three-month high of 0.0101%.

hsB0WixGYkDg4igjXsdK5SVpawLHyq5PrcHN82D5.jpeg

TON OI and funding rate. Source: Coinglass

As of press time, TON is trading at $5.77, which is up from its previous low of $5.31.

P6wPCxTDugFchrT7taB9WShcxKpSlLEH2oBdl3uQ.jpeg

French authorities are scheduled to make a statement on the detention of Telegram CEO Pavel Durov on August 26. Jinse Finance will continue to pay attention to this matter.

Source: Jinse Finance, Wikipedia, TF1, Telegram, Reuters, Guancha.com, The Block, Le Monde, CoinTelegraph

Source
Disclaimer: The content above is only the author's opinion which does not represent any position of Followin, and is not intended as, and shall not be understood or construed as, investment advice from Followin.
Like
Add to Favorites
Comments