Is this time really “different”, or is it “just the same” again? (Part 2)
— In the previous post, I explained the roles of STH-RP and TMMP, and why they’ve become the strongest resistance levels. In this thread, I’ll continue sharing my personal understanding and perspective.
Logically, this time should be “just the same”. With BTC facing dual cost-based resistance, it shouldn’t break through easily in one go. Instead, it should retrace, solidify the underlying chip structure, and let the market reconfirm the bottom consensus.
As you can see in Chart 1, there’s no obvious demand heat in the $60-70k range—the chip structure looks pretty thin here. Compare this to the dense accumulation zone formed in Feb 2022, and you’ll see the difference.
But, “will this time actually be different?”—this question has been on my mind lately. To be honest, I can sense something “unusual” quietly unfolding right in front of us.
Take <10y_RP (purple line in Chart 2) for example. This is the Realized Price calculated after excluding chips held for over 10 years (never moved), giving a more realistic market level.
In the past 13 years, there hasn’t been a single bear market where BTC didn’t break below <10y_RP. Yet this time, BTC simply refuses to drop beneath it.
During the panic from Feb-Apr this year, BTC repeatedly tested <10y_RP but never broke it. That’s no coincidence—it proves the market hit an extreme, and all selling pressure was fully absorbed.
Combine this with the “investor confidence index in the trend”—the pattern almost perfectly mirrors the last cycle, but both the volatility and duration are noticeably smaller this time (see Chart 3).
Based on all this, I personally believe we have reasons to suspect: the “atypical characteristics” of this bear market are starting to emerge.
If BTC really manages to break through both STH-RP and TMMP resistance in one shot, it’ll be the most unique bear market in BTC’s 13-year history.
Even if it doesn’t flip instantly, it could still retest and fall below STH-RP later. But once we see that first breakout, I’ll consider the market to have exited “deep bear”—entering a whole new stage: the Bear-Bull Transition.
Just like Apr 2019 to Jul 2020, and Jan to Sep 2023—periods when the market digested divergence and shifted from bear to bull sentiment (see Chart 4). During these times, we saw “one last dip” and even the possibility of a “mini bull run”.
The market is always right, regardless of our personal opinions. Past experience is just that—past. Only real action can test the truth.
Right now, there are two camps: A thinks the true bear bottom is lower; B believes $60,000 is the bottom. Which side is more likely? I don’t think it’s worth arguing.
When the market tells its story in its own unique way, our job is to read it—and “cost basis” and “price action” are its most honest language.
twitter.com/Murphychen888/stat...